Finland and NATO: How the Forgetting of Lessons of the Past Can Lead to their Repetition
Keywords:
finland, nato, russia, Baltic Region, military securityAbstract
In this article we are investigating Finland’s approach to participation in military-political alliances with its neighboring countries in the Baltic Sea region. The most active attempts to establish a regional system of collective security had been undertaken in 1920s - 1930s and were suspended shortly after the end of the Second World War. During the Cold War embeddedness of Finland into the «Nordic balance» system guaranteed strategic stability of the country in the system of complex military security relations between the Warsaw pact countries and the NATO. Furthermore being a neutral country, Finland was able to play a role of a helpful mediator between the USSR and the West. However the end of the Cold War triggered the return of Helsinki to the pursuit of an enhanced military-political integration with the European countries and the USA. Following this path for almost 25 years, Finland has abandoned its neutral status and reached the maximum possible level of integration with NATO. However, we claim that in the foreseeable future all discussions between Finnish experts and politicians about the necessity to join the NATO will not be implemented in practice for several reasons. Firstly, if Finland becomes a member of NATO, it will inevitable trigger a symmetrical military-political response from Russia and will create unnecessary difficulties in bilateral relations. Secondly, Finland has elaborated sucha sophisticated mechanism of military coordination with NATO countries, that the formal accession to the Alliance could be considered as just an excessive formality.Downloads
References
Балтийский регион. Конфликты и сотрудничество // Euroülikool, 2000.
Барышников В. Н. Советско-финляндские отношения в 1940-1941 гг. и вступление Финляндии во Вторую мировую войну // От войны к миру: СССР и Финляндия в 1939-1944 гг.: Сб. статей. СПб., 2006.
Декларация и меморандум России, Германии, Дании и Швеции по Балтийскому вопросу, 10(23) апреля 1908 г. // Мировые войны XX века. Кн. 2. Первая мировая война. Документы и материалы. М., 2002.
Дерябин Ю. Финляндия: нелегкий путь к нейтралитету // Cеверная Европа. Проблемы истории. М.: Наука, 2005.
Йокипии М. Финляндия на пути к войне. Исследование о военном сотрудничестве Германии и Финляндии в 1940-1941 гг. Петрозаводск: Изд-во Карелия, 1999.
Комаров А. А. СССР и Скандинавский оборонительный союз (1948-1949) // Северная Европа. Проблемы истории. М., 2003. Вып. 3. С. 90-101.
Межевич Н.М. Военное планирование Эстонии и Финляндии как фактор формирования систем безопасности в 1939 году // Вторая мировая война: мифы, легенды, реальность. СПб., 2010.
Шеллинг Т. Стратегия конфликта. М.: ИРИСЭН, 2007.
Anttila T. J. Uutta kupmanuutta etsimässä // Ulkopolitiikka. 2005. Is. 2.
Asmus R. American Views on Security and Cooperation in the Baltic Sea Region // 2nd Annual Stockholm Conference on Baltic Sea Security and Cooperation «Towards an Inclusive Security Structure in the Baltic Sea Region» / Ed. by Joseph P. Kuzich, Anna Fahraeus. Stockholm: 1997.
Browning C. Constructing Finnish National Identity and Foreign Policy, 1809-2000. Ph.D. Manuscript. University of Wales, Aberystwyth: 2003.
Lehti M. Baltic League as a construct of the new Europe: envisioning a Baltic region and small state sovereignty in the aftermath of the First World War. Frankfurt am Main, Berlin, Bern, New York, Paris, Wien: Lang, 1999.
Lehti M. Baltoscandia as a National Construction // Relations between the Nordic countries and the Baltic nations in the XX century. Turku: 1998.
Leskinen J. Vaiettu Suomen silta. Suomen ja Viron salainen sotilaallinen yhteistoiminta Neuvostoliiton varalta vuosina 1930-1939. Helsinki: 1997.
Lеskinen J. The silenced bridge of Finland Secret military cooperation between Finland and Estonian against the Soviet Union 1930-1939 // Россия и Финляндия в XX веке. СПб.: 1997. С. 124.
Nokkala A. Being Interested in a Big Neighbour: Russia and the Finnish Defence Establishment // Russia Forever? Towards Working Pragmatism in Finnish/Russian Relations. Aleksanteri Series. Helsinki: 2008.
Noreen Е. Den Nordiska Balansen: ett sakerhetspolotiskt begrepp i teori och praktik. Uppsala: Uppsala universitet, 1982.
Salo U. Estimation of security threats and Estonian defense planning in the 1930-s // Acta Historica Tallinnensia. 2008. Is. 12. P. 35-74.
Vihavainen T. Does history play a role in Finnish-Russian Relations? // The Two-Level Game: Russia's Relations with Great Britain, Finland and the European Union / Ed. by H. Smith. Helsinki: Aleksanteri Papers. N 2. 2006.
Virmavirta J. Mielipide: Suomen kannattaa lunastaa Nato-optio // Ulkopolitiikka. 2005. Is. 4.
Williams M. C., Neumann I. B. From Alliance to Security Community: NATO, Russia and the Power of Identity // Millennium. 2000. Vol. 29. N 2. P. 357-387.
